React vs SvelteKit for Rich Text
A detailed comparison of the two frameworks for building rich text editing applications.
Editor Availability by Framework
| Editor | React | Svelte | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| ProseMirror | Wrappers | Direct use | Framework-agnostic core. Works everywhere. |
| Tiptap | Official | Community | React gets more attention. Svelte works but less polished. |
| CodeMirror 6 | Wrappers | Direct use | Framework-agnostic. Easy to wrap in either framework. |
| Lexical | Official | No support | React-only by design. DecoratorNodes use React components. |
| Slate | Required | No support | Deeply coupled to React. Rendering IS React. |
| Plate | Required | No support | Built on Slate. Inherits React dependency. |
| BlockNote | Required | No support | React-only Notion-like editor. |
| Milkdown | Official | Official | Framework adapters for both. Equal support. |
| Editor.js | Wrappers | Direct use | Vanilla JS. Works anywhere. |
| Quill | Wrappers | Wrappers | Framework-agnostic core. |
Bundle Size
Approximate gzipped bundle sizes
Developer Experience
React
- Largest ecosystem of editor components
- Most examples and tutorials target React
- Hooks-based integration (useEditor, etc.)
- Virtual DOM can conflict with editor DOM management
- Need to be careful about re-renders
- Mature but verbose component model
SvelteKit
- Fewer ready-made editor wrappers
- Direct DOM access via actions/onMount — cleaner integration
- No virtual DOM conflicts
- Smaller bundle overhead
- Reactive stores work well with editor state
- Less boilerplate, more concise
Integration Patterns
tsx
// React: useEditor hook (Tiptap)
import { useEditor, EditorContent } from '@tiptap/react';
import StarterKit from '@tiptap/starter-kit';
function MyEditor() {
const editor = useEditor({
extensions: [StarterKit],
content: '<p>Hello</p>'
});
return <EditorContent editor={editor} />;
}svelte
<!-- Svelte: onMount + bind (Tiptap/CodeMirror/ProseMirror) -->
<script>
import { onMount } from 'svelte';
let container;
onMount(() => {
// Direct DOM access — no virtual DOM conflicts
const editor = new Editor({
element: container,
extensions: [StarterKit],
content: '<p>Hello</p>'
});
return () => editor.destroy();
});
</script>
<div bind:this={container}></div>Verdict
When to choose React
- You need Lexical, Slate, Plate, or BlockNote (React-only)
- Your team already uses React
- You need the largest possible ecosystem of editor components
When to choose SvelteKit
- You're using framework-agnostic editors (CodeMirror 6, ProseMirror, Editor.js)
- Bundle size matters
- You want cleaner DOM integration (no virtual DOM conflicts)
- You prefer less boilerplate and simpler reactivity
- Your editor needs are standard (not needing React-specific features)
Our Recommendation
SvelteKit with CodeMirror 6 for markdown editing, and SvelteKit with Tiptap/ProseMirror for rich text. The framework-agnostic editors work beautifully with Svelte's direct DOM model. React-only editors (Lexical, Slate) are excellent but not worth switching frameworks for.